Tip Trey by Nathan Kranzo

A card is freely selected, signed, and then lost in the deck. The magician runs through the deck and pulls out three cards. “Three possibilities”, the magician announces. The cards are then placed on the table in an upright position, and when the cards on either side are pulled away the center card remains standing. When the other two cards are released they fall face up revealing that they are indifferent cards. You snatch the card out of its suspended position and immediately hand it to the spectator revealing that it is their signed selection.